Father Michael & Grace Group Walkthrough Part 4
Walkthroughs for Blackwell Epiphany
Grace Church & Grace School
Head to the Police Station and ask Officer Cory Palmer about Michael's phone number. You'll find out that they've already confirmed that it's a number from Grace Church, but they don't think it was important.
Now go back to Grace Church and talk to the priest there. Ask him about Michael's phone number. Then close the notes and talk to him about The telephone. At this point the priest will slip and say Michael Cooper. Next you'll want to select the dialogue option Cooper?
End your dialogue with Father Ullman and use Rosa's phone to search for Michael Cooper. She'll get one result. Now have Rosa talk to Father Ullman again. This time use the dialogue option I know about Michael Cooper.